shirleymckie.myfastforum.org

Iain McKie · Joined: 08 May 2007 Posts: 263 Location: Ayr, Scotland.

It is refreshing to hear from one of the majority of experts who fully realise the serious allegations that the SCRO experts have to answer at this year's judicial enquiry.

http://shirleymckie.com/documents/USLetter.pdf

Meanwhile the lies of people like 'Daktari' on the 'Detail chat board' at www.clpex.com continue to provide even more proof of the poverty of the SCRO defence. To date not one single new fact has been revealed that would change my opinion that the SCRO experts, Peter Swann and Martin Leadbetter et al have an awful lot of explaining to do.

Big Wullie · Joined: 25 Apr 2007 Posts: 1149 Location: Glasgow

Hi Iain

What a great letter from America, Not a single student Identified the mark as Shirley's, she must take great comfort from this.
She must also realise not all experts are corrupt.

I have two issues that need addressing they are:

In my personal opinion, and I have been involved in fingerprint identification
for over thirty years, the cause of the problem came from the status of the
comparison being an elimination identification. I know they do not get the
same scrutiny as suspect prints. It is a quiet fact, but most people won't admit
it. I have seen it happen before, but not get out of hand as such errors are
usually kept in house and they don't get published.

Will SCRO ever admit they do not get the same scrutiny or, that it is a quiet fact ?

Second issue:

The peer pressure in forensic casework is tremendous--too many people
trying to be good friends rather than trusted colleagues. So there is more to
blame than just the incorrect four.

I greatly admire this person whoever they are for the above statement.
For having the Ba--s to come out and admit there exists "Tremendous Peer Pressure" takes great guts considering what has happened with SCRO, Edinburgh and Grampian Experts in this case.

Stevie Wonder can see the mistakes made by SCRO and so can the rest of the world.

Lets hope the Enquiry finally nails them for their criminal activities

Nought Justice · Joined: 27 Feb 2008 Posts: 39 Location: Edinburgh

Hello Iain

Very interesting

wonder if this will come out at the enquiry

surely you will cite this expert even invite some of his students along too

Best of luck for the enquiry and best to shirley